icone setor

Cross-cutting

“Program Keluarga Harapan”, PKH (Indonesia)



-% 0 -%

Authors

Margaret Triyana

Source

American Economic Journal: Economic Policy

Year

2016

Link

Intervention

Revising...

Unit of Analysis

Revising... (target)

Year

2007-2009

Country

Indonesia

Outcome Methodology Effect
Infant (0-11 months of age) mortality, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.003, Standard error: 0.003, Counterfactual mean: 0.011, Control group SD: 0.106
Birth weight, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -5.91, Standard error: 26.73, Counterfactual mean: 3180.8, Control group SD: 552.4
Low birth weight (1 if infant weights less than 2,500 grams, 0 otherwise), 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.022, Standard error: 0.012, Counterfactual mean: 0.077, Control group SD: 0.266
Maternal mortality, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.0005, Standard error: 0.0010, Counterfactual mean: 0.0008, Control group SD: 0.0003
Share of participants that used doctors, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.043, Standard error: 0.012, Counterfactual mean: 0.088, Control group SD: 0.283
Share of participants that used midwives, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.086, Standard error: 0.017, Counterfactual mean: 0.562, Control group SD: 0.496
Share of participants that used traditional attendants, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.087, Standard error: 0.016, Counterfactual mean: 0.432, Control group SD: 0.495

Intervention

Revising...

Unit of Analysis

Revising... (providers)

Year

2007-2009

Country

Indonesia

Outcome Methodology Effect
Number of doctors in the subdistricts, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.029, Standard error: 0.075, Counterfactual mean: 1.637, Control group SD: 1.009
Number of midwives in the subdistricts, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.748, Standard error: 0.190, Counterfactual mean: 9.067, Control group SD: 5.844
Number of doctors in the villages, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.004, Standard error: 0.057, Counterfactual mean: 0.348, Control group SD: 0.831
Number of midwives in the villages, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.115, Standard error: 0.022, Counterfactual mean: 1.200, p-value: 1.539
Number of traditional attendants in the villages, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.047, Standard error: 0.030, Counterfactual mean: 0.575, Control group SD: 0.971
Any private practice (1 if has a private practice, 0 otherwise), 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.001, Standard error: 0.017, Counterfactual mean: 0.894, Control group SD: 0.308
Total hours worked in the last three days in private practice, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.084, Standard error: 0.143, Counterfactual mean: 11.677, Control group SD: 11.562
Total hours worked in the last three days, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.419, Standard error: 0.746, Counterfactual mean: 28.453, Control group SD: 15.541
Total number of healh care services provided, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.580, Standard error: 0.205, Counterfactual mean: 11.808, Control group SD: 3.069
Delivery fees reported by households, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 49065, Standard error: 21085, Counterfactual mean: 298739, Control group SD: 766112
Delivery fees paid to doctors reported by households, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 40010, Standard error: 19132, Counterfactual mean: 102721, Control group SD: 746473
Delivery fees paid to midwives reported by households, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 51125, Standard error: 13670, Counterfactual mean: 176276, Control group SD: 363480
Delivery fees paid to traditional attendants reported by households, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -12886, Standard error: 2184, Counterfactual mean: 40711, Control group SD: 90292
Total income reported, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 335314, Standard error: 115473, Counterfactual mean: 3036459, Control group SD: 2304431
Fees reported for normal childbirth in public practice, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -3161, Standard error: 10554, Counterfactual mean: 128684, Control group SD: 146333
Fees reported for normal childbirth in private practice, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 27062, Standard error: 4488, Counterfactual mean: 295539, Control group SD: 141156
Reported fees received from the last 3 deliveries, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 14925, Standard error: 5806, Counterfactual mean: 335238, Control group SD: 203184
Prenatal Care Quality standardized index reported by housholds, 2 years into the cash transfer program Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: 0.072, Standard error: 0.035
Prenatal Care Quality standardized index reported in public practice, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.009, Standard error: 0.050
Prenatal Care Quality standardized index reported in private practice, 2 years into the cash transfer program (sub-sample of midwives) Randomized Controlled Trial (Average Intention-to-Treat Parameter) Magnitude: -0.021, Standard error: 0.052


User's image